Elihu Sutton

Elihu Sutton

Elihu Sutton my 3rd Great Grandfather was born in New York about 1820. Not much is known about his early life until we find him in Indiana in 1842 where he marries Caroline Elizabeth Call born in 1821 in Vermont. 

They are married in Steuben County Indiana on

 July 3rd of that year. 

 Marriage certificate from Steuben County Indiana

I mentioned in an earlier post that I believe Elihu might be living in Kendall County Illinois in 1860. 
While the ages are wrong, the names seem to fit. And I can't find Elihu anywhere else at this time. 

 1860 Census Kendall County Illinois

In 1870 Elihu and Caroline are in Jo Daviess County Illinois
near their daughter Harriet and her husband George Heath. These are my Great Great-grandparents. 

 1870 census Jo Daviess County Illinois

After their daughter Harriets death in 1873, Elihu and Caroline moved to Iowa. They are living in South Fork , Jackson County Iowa in 1880.  Their son in law George  Heath and Grand Children are living with them.

 1880 census Jackson County Iowa

In 1885 we find Elihu and his family still living in 
Jackson County Iowa. 

1885 census Jackson County Iowa

After 1885 I have no idea what happens to Elihu. Caroline died in 1900 and it seems as though Elihu has already passed away.

Caroline Sutton, February 4, 1900

Caroline Call was born in the state of Vermont, March 2, 1821; was married to Elihu Sutton, July 3, 1842; and to this union was born seven children, two boys and five girls. Two children survive, one boy and one girl, to mourn the death of this loving mother. Mrs. Sutton died at the home of Mr. Wynkoop February 4, 1900. Words of comfort were given by Elder John W. Said from St. John 3-17.

Harriet Sutton Savage Heath

Harriet is a such a sad story, but every ones story should be told.

Harriets Parents were Elihu Sutton and Caroline Call .  She was born in Indiana or New York. I think it was Indiana because her parents were married there. 

In my last post I mentioned Harriet and her husband George were living in Woodbine Twp. Jo Daviess County IL in 1870.  Well, Harriet's parents were also living nearby.

We know this is Harriet's family because in the 1880 census George is living with his In-Laws.

Harriets first husband was Thomas Savage. Their marriage is listed in Illinois Statewide Marriage Index
as having occurred on two separate dates April 20, 1859, and April 20, 1863. 

Because they are married in the 1860 Census. I believe the first date to be correct.

Thomas and Harriet had one daughter, Arminda (born 1861). Then
Thomas was called to war. He was  mustered in at Old Ripley Illinois. 
Thomas Savage was killed in the Civil War.
I believe that Thomas Savage immigrated from Ireland in 1851. 


Sometime between 1861 and 1865 Harriet came back to Northern Illinois. I'm not sure where her parents Elihu and Caroline are living in 1860. But I think it may be Kendall County IL. 
Harriet married George Heath in 1865, and had four more children John (born 1866), Caroline (born 1868), Bertha (born 1870), and  Charles (born 1873). I believe that Harriet died shortly after the birth of Charles. She was approximately 29 years old.

George Heath

Well, I thought that I wold elaborate more on George Heath. As stated in my previous post most people who are doing research on George believed him to be the son of Uriah Heath. 

But I know now that this is not the case. He is in fact the son of John H. Heath.

This is how I came to that conclusion. As most people know Genealogist work backward in time. 

So...

I knew the name of my Great Grandfather Charles Heath, and the name of his Sisters, Bertha, and Caroline. So, I look for them in the 1880 Census

 page 1

 page 2

So we know now, Charles Father's Name, George Heath. Georges lists his place of birth as New York here. But I've learned with the census, that these mistakes were easily made. 

Maybe George wasn't home when the enumerator came to call, and someone (who ever was answering the questions ) believed that George was born in New York. Or perhaps when the census was being taken the other years, a  mistake was made. 

So now we go to 1870 ( we are still traveling back in time ). 

In 1870 George is living with his wife and children in Woodbine Township, Jo Daviess  County IL. 

Now we know that sometime between 1870 and 1880 Harriet dies. 

I went to the research library in Galena Illinois, and with the help of a wonderful volunteer, I found out when Harriet died, and where she was buried. 

 Harriet E. Wife of George Heath

Still traveling back in time....
George in the 1860 census

Now we have a name for George's Father, John H. Heath. 

How do we know this is our George Heath? We try to find some other record. 

Thanks to Ancestry.com a quick search one day turned up what I had been looking a while for. 

A  marriage record for George and Harriet.  Wisconsin Marriages, 1835-1900. 

That's where the Wisconsin Historical Society comes in!

I did a genealogy search, ordered the record and waited. A few weeks later, there is was:

While I am not legally allowed to make it available to the public, and can report what is said.

Name of Husband ~ George H. Heath

Name of Father of Husband ~ John H. Heath

Name of Mother of Husband ~ (Very hard to read) looks to be Aoaline Heath

Residence of Husband ~ Shabbona 

Birthplace of Husband ~ Vermont

Full name of the wife previous to marriage ~ Harriet E. Savage

Time when the marriage was consummated ~ February 4th 1865

The place, town or township, and county, where the marriage was consummated ~ Boscobel

The color ~ White

By what ceremony was consummated ~ Justice of the Peace

Name of the person pronouncing marriage ~ Peter Rar

Residence of the person last named ~ Boscobel

Name of the person signing the certificate ~ Peter Rar

Date of certificate ~ February 6th 1865

Date of registration ~ February 21st 1865

So there you have it, George is the son of John H. Heath living in Shabbona, DeKalb county IL in 1860.

And this same family is living in Beekmantown New York in 1850.

George died at the home of his daughter, Bertha (Joseph) Bentley in Maquoketa Iowa, on February 18th 1896. 

Charles Henry Heath

Charles Henry Heath was my Grandmother's Father. He was born in Woodbine Township, JoDaviess County IL in March 1873.
His Mother died shortly after. 
He is the son of George Heath And Harriet Sutton
He and his siblings, along with their father are in the 1880 census living in Iowa with his Maternal Grandparents, Elihu Sutton and Carline Call Sutton.


 Bertha Heath Bentley, Charles Henry Heath, Caroline Heath LaFayette

Charles had an older half-sister Arminda Savage Putman. Unfortunately I don't have a picture of Arminda.


In 1897 he married my Great Grandmother Alta Clinger in Grant County Wisconsin, and they had 5 children, 4 boys and 1 girl, my Grandmother.


In 1907 his wife, my Great Grandmother passed at only 25 years old, leaving him with his 4 surviving children. By this time there is no mention of their son George, I am hoping to find out what happened to him.

From the Bellevue Herald Leader

Their Children were: Albert, Roy, Archie (Ray), and Clara.
After their Mothers death the children were separated,  Albert and Roy went to live with James Clinger their Uncle and Roy and Clara went to live with their Grandparents John and Alma Clinger.



 Archie Ray Heath Clara Heath Crosley, Albert or Roy Heath & Charles Henry Heath



Sometime before 1918 he remarried to Rosa Handy. 

Eugene Walter Crosley, Charles Heath, Bertha Bentley Heath,
Clara Heath Crosley, Archie Ray Heath, Myrtle Sprague Heath

According to my Mother he was a grounds keeper at a cemetery in Mt. Hope Wisconsin. And she also says that he is buried at Hillside Cemetery in Lancaster. She says that she had been to the grave site with my Grandmother, and that near the south east fence, but there is no grave marker. I have searched and not found any sign of his grave. Charley died in 1949.